That is ridiculous! I think you have a cute house and (no offence) I don't think it was as nice when you bought it as it is now I know how much work you both have done to it!
I don't think you can fight the appraisers, but you should - people should be rewarded for increasing the value of their home not penalized!
LOL! No offense taken. This house was a mess when we bought it! As my older son said, it felt like a little house that we had inherited from an elderly relative rather than an actual purchase...
HOUSE, THEN
front porch
BACK PORCH
bathroom (note the fuse box on the wall to the far left! the house inspector about fainted...we now have a breaker box away from water sources!)
living room, complete with 1970s wall paneling...somehow I failed to take a pic of the wall-to-wall baby blue carpet that was in here