Not an expert, but I did use lye on cherry some 30 years ago and now am finishing (adding-on) to this project after raising the kids! A cabinetmaker friend of mine suggested pottasium dichromate. I am in the midst of testing the differences myself. First impression is that the lye portion is a bit redder compared to the PD which seems browner. But still testing - I'll keep you posted.I have a new cherry table that I want to age to match 200 year old cherry furniture. Of course, I could stain. But I saw someone age cherry in about 1 min. with lye. I am about to experiment with this. I understand I will rinse and then stabilize with vinegar. Has anyone else had experience with this and perhaps tips? thanks