Originally Posted by sasjzl
<snip>Another bandsaw question. In the Woodcraft catalog I see "Carter Bandsaw Blade Stabilizers" on page 19 of the July-August 2009 issue. It costs $80 and looks like an excellent idea. On the next page though I see "Band Saw Roller Guides" for a few dollars less. Has anyone used either on of these blade stabilizing add ons? The only thing I would worry about on the Roller Guides is the risk of the round bearings that the blade would roll on getting chewed up if the blade was not adjusted correctly. I would not think it would take long for this to happen.
Thanks again for all the info. Now I know where to get parts for Delta.
Jim Lee
Assuming you mean the "Bandrollers" (tm), then they and the Carter guide do slightly different things.
The Carter is designed to support small blades and it replaces the thrust bearing. But it doesn't eliminate the need for side support, except in very narrow blades.
The Bandrollers are that side support..but they don't eliminate the need for a thrust bearing.
If you follow proper set-up procedure, the bandrollers will never touch the blade. I have had something very similar on my Hitachi resaw for years with never a problem. IMO, the biggest problem with these roller-style guides is that by their design, the blade has less support - less contact area and the roller touches the blade higher - than with a block-style guide.
I would not replace cool blocks with the bandrollers unless you are having a clear problem with the cool blocks. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
-Mark